Law Practice,
Ethics/Professional Responsibility
Nov. 7, 2025
How trial lawyers win: Turning the courtroom into a theater of truth
Every trial is a battle of stories, and the one that makes jurors feel the facts -- not just hear them -- is the one that wins.
Baruch C. Cohen
Law Office of Baruch C. Cohen APLC
4929 Wilshire Blvd Ste 940
Los Angeles , CA 90010
Phone: (323) 937-4501
Fax: (323) 937-4503
Email: BCC4929@gmail.com
Every trial begins as a clash of narratives, competing stories vying not merely for acceptance, but for belief. Evidence alone rarely decides a case; meaning does. Jurors don't just weigh facts, they feel them. The side that translates dry exhibits into living experience, that connects law to life, wins hearts before it wins verdicts. In every courtroom, reason and emotion share the same witness stand. A skilled trial lawyer knows how to cross-examine both.
Facts convince, stories compel
A pile of documents is not a case. It's a corpse until breathed into by narrative. A story animates facts, orders chaos and gives moral architecture to the evidence. When a trial lawyer weaves a timeline into a journey, with conflict, courage, betrayal and redemption, the jury stops seeing "Exhibit 12" and starts seeing a human being.
Great advocates don't just argue; they translate. They take what their client endured and render it into a language the heart understands.
The pulse beneath persuasion
To tell a client's story is to reveal pulse beneath paper. It's to make the jury feel the cost of injustice, to sense the breathless pause before a verdict that will echo for a lifetime. You cannot fake that heartbeat. It's born of authenticity, empathy and the courage to be emotionally transparent in a profession that rewards armor. Because beneath every closing argument lies something primal, the oldest human impulse: the need to be heard.
The anatomy of a winning narrative
A winning story at trial has rhythm. It begins with purpose, gains traction through conflict and resolves through truth. Every good story answers three silent questions the jury is always asking: Why should I care? Can I trust you? Does justice demand a response? The lawyer who answers those questions with sincerity, not slogans, earns not just a verdict, but also respect.
Where battles are won before they begin: The power of voir dire
That is why cases can be won or lost at voir dire -- jury selection. It's not just about finding sympathetic jurors or dismissing the problematic ones; it's about identifying those rare individuals willing to listen, to truly hear the story and weigh it with open minds. Voir dire is where the seeds of justice are planted. While closing arguments let the attorney swing for the fences, the real foundation of victory is laid long before, when 12 citizens are chosen not for their bias, but for their capacity to believe in truth.
The art of the storyteller
The art of the storyteller is not child's play; it is the soul of persuasion. A gifted trial lawyer doesn't just tell the story; he invites the fact-finder into it. He transforms jurors from passive listeners into participants who see through his client's eyes, feel their fear and share their hope. Through pacing, tone and truth, he builds a world inside the courtroom where every exhibit breathes and every witness becomes part of a living narrative. The talented storyteller doesn't argue -- he transports. And when the fact-finder lives the story, justice ceases to be theoretical; it becomes undeniable.
The moral weight of words
Those who tell the best story win, but "best" does not mean manipulative. It means true. It means courageous enough to expose complexity, to admit imperfections, to humanize both sides of the conflict. The client's story must illuminate, not distort -- elevate, not exploit. A trial is not theater for ego; it is theater for truth. And truth, when told with grace and conviction, always finds its audience.
Built for the battle: Where courage replaces comfort
A lawyer who boasts he's never lost a case isn't revealing mastery -- he's revealing fear. It means he's either never actually tried a case or only takes safe ones, avoiding risk and the raw silence before a verdict when everything hangs in the balance. Trial work isn't about perfection; it's about courage. To never lose is to never risk. And to never risk is to never truly advocate.
I've met many attorneys who live in the comfort zone of calculated caution, lawyers who build entire careers avoiding uncertainty, who have never felt the pulse of a courtroom or the weight of 12 silent jurors watching truth take shape. But not me. I was built for trial, where truth is tested, risk is embraced and courage, not comfort, decides the outcome.
When justice comes alive
That is why I push for trial -- because only in trial, where truth faces cross-examination and story meets scrutiny, does justice come alive. Motions and settlements may end disputes, but they don't expose truth.
Trial is revelation. It's where testimony unmasks motive, where paper becomes pulse and where 12 citizens decide whose story deserves belief. In that arena, justice isn't argued -- it's felt. And when justice is felt, it becomes real.
The advocate as storyteller of the soul
At our best, we trial lawyers are translators of human struggle, sculptors of chaos into coherence. We stand between fact and feeling, law and life, crafting stories that honor both justice and humanity. Our craft is not deception; it's revelation. It's finding the heartbeat in the brief, the conscience in the code. Because when the jury files out, what endures isn't the statute you cited -- it's the story you told.
Submit your own column for publication to Diana Bosetti
For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:
Email
Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com
for prices.
Direct dial: 213-229-5424
Send a letter to the editor:
Email: letters@dailyjournal.com
