Scott Dormer emphasizes preparation, candor in volunteer mediation

For Scott Bradley Dormer, successful mediation begins long before the parties enter the room.

"I spend about an hour in advance of each mediation to prepare," Dormer said. "At the start of the mediation I review the entirety of the case with both sides in a straightforward, unbiased manner."

Dormer, who has practiced plaintiff's personal injury law for nearly 35 years, brings that preparation to his work as a volunteer settlement officer for the Los Angeles County Superior Court's Mediation Volunteer Panel. He has served on the MVP panel since its inception in November 2024 after spending about two years with Resolve Law LA. In addition to his litigation practice at the Law Office of Scott Bradley Dormer, he also conducts private mediations through Dormer Dispute Resolution.

Dormer said he volunteered because he recognizes the need to help courts resolve cases more efficiently.

"As an active plaintiff's personal injury attorney, I recognize the need to assist the Court in resolving cases to help clear the calendar and increase access to justice for all litigants," he said. "Additionally, I consider it my honor to volunteer time for the Court and community and use my skills to help settle cases."

His years as a litigator give him credibility with both plaintiffs and defendants, he said, allowing him to candidly discuss the strengths and weaknesses of each side's case.

"There are strengths and weaknesses in every case, and both sides need to be aware of these," Dormer said.

He also believes plaintiffs should play an active role in the mediation process rather than leaving negotiations entirely to counsel.

"For the Plaintiff's side, I involve the Plaintiff themselves in the discussion to ensure they have had an opportunity to be heard," he said. "That they can participate fully and understand the issues in their case ... is very important."

Dormer said the greatest obstacle to settlement is when one side becomes entrenched in its own analysis and loses sight of the risks of continued litigation. Even so, he believes nearly every dispute can be mediated if the parties approach the process with an open mind.

Although he appreciated the opportunity to co-mediate through Resolve Law, Dormer said he prefers the MVP program because it allows him to direct the discussions and negotiations himself.

He typically handles four volunteer mediations each month while maintaining an active personal injury practice and a private mediation calendar, mediating between 30 and 40 Superior Court cases last year.

His advice to attorneys considering volunteer mediation is simple.

"Do it," Dormer said. "It is a necessary need for the Court and the community, and you will improve your ability to analyze cases, discuss with counsel and get them settled."