Labor/Employment
Nov. 20, 2026
Plaintiffs' lawyers shouldn't wait until summary judgment to build their cases
Plaintiffs' employment lawyers should prepare to defeat summary judgment from the first client interview by developing a clear case theory, testing the evidence and pursuing targeted discovery.
Steven I. Azizi
Founding Partner
Miracle Mile Law Group LLP
Phone: (213) 433-3588
Email: steven@miraclemilelaw.com
It has been 18 months since a plaintiff's employment lawyer filed a client's discrimination case in superior court. It is Friday night, and the weekend has finally arrived. Then an email lands from opposing counsel serving defendant's motion for summary judgment. Hundreds of material facts. Panic sets in. Is there enough evidence to win? Were the right depositions taken? Were the right questions asked? These are fair inquiries.
But preparation for an MSJ in an employment case should begin long before the complaint is filed--potentially at the first client interview. With early enough preparation, the case may never face an MSJ at all. Good defense lawyers know when plaintiff's counsel has done the work. When the evidence is developed and the case is positioned to survive summary judgment, the defense must choose: discuss settlement or prepare for trial. Either way, plaintiff's counsel is in the driver's seat--the best place for a plaintiff's employment lawyer to be.
Intake
It sounds arduous, but preparing for an MSJ begins the day the case is signed. From the outset, counsel should have a working theory of the case. Employment cases are complex stories. The client is the protagonist. The company--along with HR, the supervisor, and any other bad actors--is the antagonist. Co-workers are the supporting cast. The attorney of record is the director, whose job is to make sense of the story with a theme and narrative that will sway a jury. That theory also guides the discovery plan. Testing it from the defense's side shows counsel what must be attacked in the early stages of truth-finding.
Intake is also the time to test the sufficiency of the client's documentary evidence: texts, emails, and any other correspondence that may surface in discovery. Verifying the client's account through documents saves time and money, and the evidence collected at intake alone is sometimes enough to defeat an MSJ. It is far better to discover the worst fact in the case at intake than 18 months later as an exhibit to the defense's motion.
Pre-litigation efforts
Before filing, plaintiff's counsel has a meaningful opportunity to learn something that becomes critical at summary judgment: the defense's version of the story. Many attorneys scoff at pre-litigation settlement efforts, and understandably so. Corporate defendants often ignore demand letters, lowball the plaintiff's bar, or participate in pre-suit mediation in bad faith. But skipping this stage leaves value on the table. The goal is not necessarily settlement; the real value is free information that narrowly tailors discovery from the start. A substantive response to a demand letter reveals why the employer claims the termination was legitimate, which facts are disputed, which witnesses the defense will rely on, and--most importantly--whether the client failed to disclose material facts. It may even expose a dispositive weakness before significant time and money are invested.
Pre-litigation efforts can also surface insurance coverage and policy limits, an ironclad arbitration agreement, or an insolvent defendant. Plaintiffs' lawyers do not have unlimited resources; they must learn as much as they reasonably can about the facts, defenses, forum, insurance, and collectability.
None of this means showing the entire hand. There is a stark difference between advocating for the client and handing the defense a road map. The defense should get just enough to take the case seriously--but no one should do its homework for it.
Pleading
Once the client's story checks out, counsel faces one of the most important decisions in the case: which causes of action to pursue. Each carries elements that must be proven with admissible evidence. The temptation to throw everything at the wall should be resisted. California employment law is expansive--FEHA, the Labor Code, contract claims, defamation, and more--but every cause of action pleaded gives the defense another avenue to a partial victory, and weak claims distract from strong ones. An opposition brief has a page limit, and every sentence spent defending a weak claim is one not spent on the strongest. A narrowly tailored complaint keeps discovery, depositions, and the eventual opposition focused on the claims that matter.
Written discovery
Too often, written discovery is treated as something that simply needs to "go out": boilerplate requests meant to capture anything that might matter. A better approach works backward from the causes of action. For each claim, counsel should ask: What must be proven? What evidence already exists? What is still needed, and who has it?
The most important evidence--internal emails, investigative materials, comparator evidence--is usually controlled by the defendant, and defendants fight tooth and nail to keep it. Multiple motions to compel are common. Narrow, targeted requests put counsel in a far stronger position when explaining to a judge why the defense must produce. The purpose of written discovery is deliberate: to build the record needed to create genuine disputes of material fact.
One set is rarely the last. Follow-up discovery is especially powerful after favorable deposition testimony; defense counsel struggles to withhold information its own witness just said exists. Written discovery guides depositions, and depositions inform the next round of requests.
Depositions
Depositions are where document production becomes admissible evidence, and the MSJ opposition will hinge on the admissions obtained there. No deposition should begin without counsel knowing exactly what testimony is needed. Before each one, counsel should review the elements of every claim, the documents produced, and the employer's stated reasons, then build the examination around the admissions that will create triable issues.
MSJ: It should not be a surprise
When the motion finally arrives on a Friday night, it should not trigger panic. If the theory was built at intake, tested before filing, pleaded with precision, and developed through targeted discovery and depositions, the evidence needed to oppose summary judgment is already in the file. The best MSJ opposition is built long before the motion is ever served.
Submit your own column for publication to Diana Bosetti
For reprint rights or to order a copy of your photo:
Email
Jeremy_Ellis@dailyjournal.com
for prices.
Direct dial: 213-229-5424
Send a letter to the editor:
Email: letters@dailyjournal.com